29 Heartfelt Lyrics From Benson Boone’s Sophomore Album, American Heart, to Use as Captions
Benson Boone truly has been one of the defining viral artists of 2025, and with the release of his sophomore album, American Heart, he only cements that status even further.
Featuring 10 tracks and clocking in at 30 minutes and 27 seconds, the effortlessly catchy album is short but very sweet, putting Benson's bold pop persona front and center as he gravitates behind theatrically fun tracks and deeply heartfelt anthems, straight from the soul. It's a rare no-skip project, and below, we've collected all of its most memorable lyrics—and some guidance on how to use them as your next photo caption.
For running into your ex with your new partner:
"I'm sorry, I'm here for someone else, but it's good to see your face."
-"Sorry I'm Here for Someone Else"
For not being sure if it's meant to last:
"Far from perfect for each other, but we're workin' it out, I suppose (I suppose)."
-"Sorry I'm Here for Someone Else"
For doing what you had to do:
"But I need to go (I need to, I need to, I need to). It's not personal."
-"Sorry I'm Here for Someone Else"
For that reunion with a past love:
"You were always the one I shoulda waited for. I can't lose you again, not again, not again, not again."
-"Sorry I'm Here for Someone Else"
Also read about: 20 Emotional Benson Boone Lyrics to Use as Your Next Instagram Caption
For the heartthrob you simply can't resist:
"Heaven knows, yeah, they made him out of fire and roses with an attitude."
-"Mr Electric Blue"
For when someone new takes over all of your fantasies:
"He can be everything you've ever dreamed."
-"Mr Electric Blue"
For being jealous of someone's perfection:
"I don't mind if this is gonna take a million days. I know you'll come around to me eventually."
-"Mr Electric Blue"
For when you're purely infatuated:
"When you pull me in and you hold me close and you say all kinds of crazy things that make me wanna stay in your arms. You're a charm, I'm in love."
-"Man in Me"
(American Heart via Night Street Records)
Also read about: How Writing 'In the Stars' Helped Benson Boone Grapple With Loss
For feeling anything but free:
"Don't you see that lately I've been fading? I can't breathe inside this cage."
-"Man in Me"
For dealing with dishonesty:
"Even the sweetest words, they were treason 'cause you just lied to my face."
-"Man in Me"
For when they're not feeling it anymore:
"There's nothing colder than your shoulder when you're dragging me along like you do."
-"Mystical Magical"
For when you're willing to be patient:
"I don't mind if this is gonna take a million days. I know you'll come around to me eventually."
-"Mystical Magical"
Also read about: Benson Boone Illuminates the Stage on His Fireworks & Rollerblades World Tour
For knowing it's just a matter of time before you win their heart:
"Once you know what my love's gonna feel like, nothing else will feel right."
-"Mystical Magical"
For when your crush is unobtainable:
"My little hard-to-get baby, I wanna give you the world."
-"Mystical Magical"
For your post-breakup souvenirs:
"You got a couple little candles in my living room I still light at night just to set the mood."
-"Reminds Me of You"
For when you just can't get over them:
"And, ooh, what do I do? What do I do? When every damn thing reminds me of you."
-"Reminds Me of You"
Also read about: Benson Boone Talks 'Sugar Sweet,' Its Serendipitous Music Video and His 'First Real Tour'
For wishing your mom were here:
"Momma, I'm missing home."
-"Momma Song"
For lamenting the passage of time:
"I'm getting old. Does that mean you're getting older, and older, and older?"
-"Momma Song"
For cherishing the moments you have with someone:
"I'm gonna need this when I'm holding pictures of you and that's all that I've got left."
-"Momma Song"
For trying to find what you're missing:
"I'm looking for a little peace."
-"I Wanna Be the One You Call"
Also read about: Benson Boone Reveals the Powerful Love Story Behind His New Single, 'Before You'
For yearning to be theirs:
"I just need your number, so, if you're alone, I wanna be the one you call."
-"I Wanna Be the One You Call"
For vowing to be there for them:
"When you need anything, anything at all, I wanna be the name you scream."
-"I Wanna Be the One You Call"
For feeling extra bold:
"Excuse me, I haven't met you before, but I believe that you'll be taking me home."
-"Wanted Man"
For finally feeling seen:
"You'rе making me feel like I'm wanted."
-"Wanted Man"
Also read about: Benson Boone Takes the Time to Figure Himself Out in Single 'Better Alone' and Teases New EP
For a fateful reunion:
"I am glad to see your eyes ain't changed at all."
-"Take Me Home"
For meeting up with an old flame:
"Kiss me, kiss me slowly, like you did when we were young."
-"Take Me Home"
For finding a sense of home again:
"Take me home. I've been lost on my own."
-"Take Me Home"
Also read about: American Idol Alum Benson Boone Dishes on His Stunning Debut Single, 'Ghost Town'
For the freedom and potential of summer:
"We're just floating, so wild and free, and it all made sense to me."
-"Young American Heart"
For wanting nothing but to be by their side:
"I'd be just fine as long as I'm wherever you are, 'causе you stole my young, American heart."
-"Young American Heart"
Can't get enough of Benson? Click HERE to discover everything he shared about himself with us as our Man Crush Monday.